As far as the libel thing goes, I don’t believe an instance where people are discussing whether or not the comments of a poster constitutes trolling can reasonably be construed as libel any more than a discussion of whether or not someone is being a jerk.  It’s a subjective interpretation: a conclusion that isn’t actually harmful to anyone’s reputation or livelihood. It’s certainly a violation of the no personal attacks rule, however. 

The conversation might have been possible within the strictures of Renderosity as a generalized debate on what constitutes trolling and trolls. There was no need to point out a possible troll . 

 

Download my free stuff here: http://www.renderosity.com/homepage.php?page=2&userid=323368