I personally don't like this system. I'd prefer the rule violations to be in the user profile. Maybe in the private zone, if you are concerned about privacy, like the account informations or the orders history. But definitely visible by the interested user in each moment, not stored "somewhere" and retrieved IF and WHEN requested. Retrieved by who? The same person who wrote the violation? What was the exact wording of the violation? Which details were recorded? Is there a severity range? Are the details stored in a database? Who can read them? How can I be sure they are not changed arbitrarily?

If users could see their violation records in every moment, these questions would be answered at once.

(In my case, I'd not mind if my details could be read by everyone, but it's just a personal opinion.)

Sorry if my English is awful. I hope that my thought is clear.

Giorgio

giorgio_2004 here, ksabers on XBox Live, PSN  and everywhere else.