aeilkema, "for me the characters don't come to life.."

I don't understand at all. There is no way 3D models can be made life-like no matter how skilled you are. Just try to put a Poser model in a photograph and it looks completely out of place. 3D models are meant to be used for games and animated film, advertising.

But if we are talking about 2D stills (called "Art" by some), then all depends on the skill of the artist. I believe Raphael and Caravagio was mentioned? I don't think anyone doubt that those gentlemen would be just as outstanding in digital media as they were with paint and brush.