Mehndi, the neftis aspect to this thread was added by those who see hypocrisy from Dmentia and her supporters. I don't believe anyone has said that neftis was necessarily innocent, just that a lynch mob attacked her publicly with no evidence of guilt offered publicly. The sheer number of attackers in the neftis thread makes an interesting comparison to the handful supporting Staale here, who at least posted some public evidence to back his public accusation. No matter how irritated you feel about the neftis thing, you should not keep alluding to her guilt while suggesting folk desist from 'lynching' Dmentia. Of course, it doesn't behove those who saw the neftis incident as terrible to engage in the same practises themselves... sbnox's reaction to your adjudication offer may have been because he was guilty, or it may have been because he believed you prejudged him. His silence did not indicate guilt (though his 'work' almost certainly did).