Forum: Vue


Subject: the perfect Vue computer

FCLittle opened this issue on Feb 26, 2009 · 90 posts


Rutra posted Sat, 04 April 2009 at 5:16 PM

Quote - "Well, I do think education has something to do with knowledge."

Yes, I agree. The key word is something, and as it is your own italic on that word I assume you agree on this.
I have seen highly educated people who are lousy IT professionals and people with no formal academic background who are five star IT experts. So, education has something to do with knowledge but, by itself, does not constitute an evidence that the person is correct in his/her opinions.
Knowledge should speak for itself. When a display of knowledge needs to be acompanied by a statement of "I have a background in xxxx" (replace "xxxx" by the field of expertise of your choice), then something is wrong. It probably means that the person is not very confident in his/her own opinions, and/or has doubts that his/her opinions will be valid by itself, and so needs to back it up with something. This immediately raises lots of doubts in my mind about the validity of whatever that person is saying.

But the heart of the matter of this thread is "perfect Vue computer". Things like statistics or aluminum cases are "fait divers", only partially relevant for this discussion. Until now, I have not seen my arguments pro-PC defeated. I do not claim to have the ultimate truth, nor even to have any truth at all. I just have arguments and I will very humbly bow to whoever proves my arguments are wrong, one by one. Let me repeat them once more (copy+paste from 2 or 3 posts ago):