Quote - Ok, am I to understand then that the generall idea of renderosity comment function is not constructive critique/feedback but rather people just giving eachother a pat on the back with a smile and a comment like "Nice picture!" And that the only place people really give critique is in Critique Forum? It feels like such a shame as there obiously is so much activity here, I just think it is strange and a bit sad that people in generall are so "afraid" to give critisism when people post with the constructive critisism optioned. I would say 97% of all the comment I see is with style: I comment you and then you with a generall "Beutiful,nice!"

Sorry if I sound so negative, I just really like Renderosity and think it would be more interesting if people could actually analyze farther than a generall "nice picture" comment.

I will check out the Critique forum again and look around :D

No, that's not what they're saying...lol. What they ARE saying is that people's feelings get hurt very quickly so therefore MOST people just give general "Nice image" and all that from experience of the backlashes...lol. People CAN give contructive criticism in a comment if they so choose - I personally appreciate it on my images. No one knows how imperfect my things are than me! lol. When I allow comments that's what I encourage. Sadly, not everyone does. Some DO need a pat on the back and only that and take it the wrong way when you point something out that may be wrong, however tactfully :o(.

Laurie