Winterclaw opened this issue on Sep 09, 2009 · 39 posts
Vestmann posted Thu, 10 September 2009 at 5:45 PM
Quote -
To put it another way: you don't have to be a musician to perform "folk music." People who perform classical music are generally musicians (keep in mind that I'm not saying they are necessarily professional or paid).
Hmmm I think this would call for another thread about what we call a musician. To me you don't need a diploma or classical training to be a musician. I know musicians who have had a lot of schooling and training and that by no means makes them a good musician. On the other hand there are popular musicians who have very little training but have a good way speaking to us through their music. That's a good musician and an artist.
A classical musician playing from notes something that was written hundreds years ago maybe a good musician but not much of an artist. You could say the classical musician is painting by numbers while a good pop/rock musician is painting from heart. Who would you say is more of an artist?