Egad, I spent about five times as much time on this render than the last one, I can't make it look like the other one.

The wall texture, like the other one, is procedural. The wall geometry was exported from a modeler, everything else is straight Poser.

There is a low intensity IBL set to dark blue. There is a low intensity infinite light set to the same dark blue with its diffuse component dialed down. And of course there's an orange spot light, which has a 4X multiply node into light intensity in order to see it's affect on the wall. This unfortunately blows out the specular, which dialed way down.

I still like the first image better and it took far less time to tune.