I asked my wife that know nothing and isn't interested about CG what she think about this pictures, she think the first one is a photograph with the smile made up in photoshop LOL, and inmediatly sayed the second one is not real "too much perfection covered by forced inperfections" she sayed, now if you ask me I like both of them a lot, and the mos real I've ever seen is the psuedo-Polaroid that dlfuman say at CGTALK.