As to the entire 2D debate..

I think the second Q&A that Gradient made reference to is a decent statement..

I'm not sure who wrote those..

The rule of thumb we use is when an image no longer resembles a photo.. It's not really specific..
I could run a photo thru a single filter in photoshop and make it no longer look like a photo..

The bottom line is, this is a Photography Gallery..

It's for your original Photographs..I don't want this discussion to turn into a a big issue.. It seems we have some strong beliefs on both sides of the aisle here.

I am however glad to see this going on becuase it helps the staff to to understand the feeling with in our community..

www.bclaytonphoto.com

bclaytonphoto on Facebook