Anthanasius opened this issue on Oct 15, 2009 · 48 posts
Vestmann posted Thu, 15 October 2009 at 7:55 PM
Quote - Similarly, if you spend a week modeling in Max, and render in Poser, it is still a Poser image, not a Max image. The image came from Poser. Maybe the props or figures in it came from elsewhere but so what. I've heard that V4 was modeled in Modo. So if you load V4 and click render in Poser, is that a Modo render? Hardly.
Maybe V4 was modeled in Modo but she doesn't come packaged for Modo when you buy her does she? She doesn't come packaged for Max, C4D, Vue or Notepad. No she comes ready for Poser and DS. If you look at a render of V4 I bet most users out there would connect her with Poser or DS. No matter how many fancy lights and render elements she has around her.
If someone has labored for a week in Max, modeling a car, only to post it as a Poser render in the Poser gallery, I might ask "Hey where can I get that car?" only to find out someone had been so stupid to render in Poser in stead of Max ;) That's hardly fair either is it?
Maybe we expect different things from the Poser section. I really don´t like untouched renders and I don't understand the "no postwork, just render" WOW factor. No matter how good a render looks, it will always look better after a bit of surgical postwork IMO.