I have an idea.

Clearly there are people who want critique, and clearly there are people who do NOT want critique.

Let's make a "club" -- someone whip up a badge in photoshop that people can use to let everyone else know they are interested in actual critique. People wearing the badge, then, can be expected to dish and receive harsh critique on their work, as they want. People without the badge can continue their joyfest.

Good idea?