What is the problem with doing both? I like to think this is how I approach my own work.

Yes, I tweak and tweak and tweak. That is why I bought a really high powered computer to do my renders, so that I never get a render that takes more than an hour in IDL. I WANT the technique to be as flawless as my talent and limited expertise will allow. That's why I buy good models and props. I take advantage of the talent the modelers have put forth.

But in the end, it is the story I'm trying to tell that is important. I FULLY agree that if this element is weak or missing, all of the technical expertise that even a Bagginsbill can bring to bear will be wasted.

Looking at your work, I see nothing to criticize technically. You obviously are a competent Poser operator! :) If YOU are unhappy with the content, then by all means concentrate there FIRST, but don't forget to go back and do the tweaking AFTER you have the concept you seek.

I think to ignore either facet is to throw the baby out with the bathwater, and will cause your work to suffer accordingly.

My $.02

Doug