I haven't been at this forum for very long. This was my first challenge that I entered (on time) and I was able to find the rules and read them a few times to make sure I was in spec. What better way to learn what the rules are than to be held to them. It might be disappointing BUT how dissappointing to the person who played by rules who would have won? The FAQ is in plain site for everyone. That should be enough. Doesn't that seem fair to Everybody? You don't want to punish the people who do pay attention.