josterD opened this issue on Sep 12, 2010 · 51 posts
232bird posted Thu, 16 September 2010 at 12:12 AM
I have used Poser, Daz, 3ds Max, C4D, etc. What I have noticed most about the rendering is that the higher end (ahem, $$$) programs have better render engines. Firefly is ancient, and although I respect what SM has done to keep it somewhat current ( actually think it is quite a value if you compare render quality vs. dollar to the other programs), I don't think it calculates lighting as in-depth as the other engines. It was born before global illumination and multi-core home PCs became commonplace. For example look back through the gallery a couple years. There are some renders that look so good I couldn't tell if they were CGI at first, and that was before VSS and GI, but they were done with fifteen lights in the scene. Or play with LuxPose the uber-users have been creating. Render the same scene in firefly then export it to LuxRender, it will be 10x better. And take 10x longer. That's just what I have noticed. Laurie, you have seen it all. Any thoughts?