One of the things that attracted me to Rendo in the first place was that the members are not stupidly critical about EVERYTHING. There are many sites (I'm sure we all know of a few) where people who wouldn't know a lens from a leg rip into every photo, finding faults that are not there, and generally squeezing every last bit of fun out of a shot. You could take a photo of the second coming of Christ, and someone would jump straight on it saying:

• 'You should have got your model to shave to show off the childlike qualities of the piece'.
• 'Crosses are sooooo 2009, nailing him to a circle would unite the background with the DOF's POV and CCD'.
• 'I find Mary sobbing in the background a little distracting. You need to photoshop her out'.
• 'FAKE....you can see the cloning around his wrists'!

Sometimes a photo just IS WHAT IT IS. Constructive suggestions are great, but in my experience, the power to comment on other people's work is seldom used wisely.