I do not know much about photography nor renders but as i say-I do know what i like,

If someone post's a comment stating terrific capture if it is not then you are not helping anyone.

If i post a crap picture i want someone to be honest and say that it is crap.

No Person will get better if people make them feel good about a bum picture.

Yes be honest but try to help us ( the beginners ) by advising us on what is wrong without making out that we are total idiot's.

We are not professional's-I have been taking picture's for nearly four week's now and i enjoy it and generally i will give a five but i only do so because the picture appeal's to me as an individual.

As jayfar stated people would be disheartened if they get knocked-Of course they would-But simply by telling them how to improve on thing's at the same time would make the blow less hurtful...

He farther states that everyone think's there images are the best---Well they are not ( Mine are ).

Everybody like different thing's and see's things differently.

I hate when i cannot state on a render for example that the lighting is brilliant-I know nothing about them so how could i?

When i comment it is because i like or do not like olain and simple....

Some people once told me not so long ago that an image would be better off without a frame whilst another said that they liked it.

It did not bother me so i left the images without frames after that and decided that if people wanted a picture they could then frame it themselves...

You can't please everyone all of the time but you can listen to their comment's good or bad without taking offence-Unless of course they are constantly running you down.

Give me a bad comment any time that you want-But i will not hit back by giving you one-I will try to improve on what is said...

So comment away people good or bad.

If people cannot accept an honest opinion the they should turn the comment option off.

I can't half talk can't i ?

Equal right's for photographer's because i will be one - one day...................