FutureFantasyDesign opened this issue on Sep 10, 2011 · 342 posts
philebus posted Mon, 19 September 2011 at 1:10 PM
Quote - You're arguing about your contribution. I'm arguing about the semantics of the phrase CG Artist.
Everyone in the pipeline is an artist. But what is the role denoted by the term "CG Artist"?
By analogy:
In music, you are not a "composer" if you merely perform the works of others (player), or you conduct the performance (conductor), or you arrange the score followed by the players and conductors (arranger). That's why you see albums with a credit like "Harry Nilson - Composer, Arranger, Conductor, Pianist", and not simply "Harry Nilson - Musical Artist".
When those are four different people, they are all still musicians, all still artists, but those four jobs are different jobs and have words to identify them.
Or...CG Artist can refer to someone who produces work that is Computer Generated. To keep to analogies, Film has a range of divisions such as Directors, DPs, Script Writers, etc. Within that industry there is the Auteur, which is not a perfect analogue but serves better than CG Artist, lacking its ambiguity.