Khai-J-Bach opened this issue on Aug 06, 2012 · 149 posts
monkeycloud posted Sat, 11 August 2012 at 12:22 PM
Sure... the reality is they likely won't though... I simply suspect, in practical terms, if anyone is going to do anything with it, it'll be on the basis I alluded to.
Personally, I'd rather the advanced stuff is still there, so the likes of BB can still extend it...
...and the likes of me can manage to glean a little bit more than I might otherwise about how things are actually working under the hood.
To contribute yet another terrible analogy to a thread already laden with them... the closest I get to motor mechanics these days is changing the washer fluid. I don't generally even change the oil myself.
But if I get a choice of a car whose bonnet opens up and one which doesn't, I'd generally pick the former...
...that preference maybe isn't entirely rational of me. But, I have it...
EDIT: Sorry re-reading your post Laurie, and Basicwiz's I suspect I misinterpreted...?
...so in that sense, yes, it would be better, I suspect if SM actually implemented the idea of an intermediate mat room, sure.
In terms of just abandoning the nodes underneath. I don't think they should do that...
...and I really do think BB's shader work should be encompassed into the necessary presets in any intermediate preset-type system too.