It depends I think.

I usually would never vote for an image which has all over blood, cutted body parts etc. Even when it is technically well made. But this is not my kind of taste, so I would vote for an Image with less violance, even when it would have some technical ( small ) issues.

But at last the overal count. Light, mood, Postwork, technic...the idea behind.

La vie est éternelle. L'amour est immortel.

“Dwell on the beauty of life. Watch the stars, and see yourself running with them.”
― Marcus Aurelius,