I don't know.  It's... okay.

To me, it feels like they couldn't decide on "light" or "dark" and so we have both.

Medium to dark grey forums, big white buttons, white borders around the avatars.  Dark grey or black button I think would have been more slick looking.  IMHO, it's too much of ... this is black on white but this over here is white on grey.  It feels disconnected.

I'm not in love in with the line between each forum post either on the main forum page.  I think striping would have looked better.

.