Forum: 3D Modeling


Subject: Has anyone used Silo?

scullygirl818 opened this issue on Oct 30, 2012 · 47 posts


LuxXeon posted Fri, 20 December 2013 at 4:40 PM

Quote - This kind of addresses the other obstacle about switching to Blender.  Aside from the UI, which isn't a deal breaker,  Blender is still lacking a few really important workflow features I use daily in Max, and I'd hate to have to learn yet another application just to suppliment that.  I use a feature in Max called Xview mode, which is basically an automated way to inspect your model, and can locate any mesh errors, or unwanted issues like crossed edges, isolated verts, ngons, issues with the UV's, etc.  It highlights the location of these problem areas, making it very simple to go in and fix them, if need be.  This is something I depend on heavily in my workflow, and would sorely miss if I had to switch.  Does Blender have such tools, perhaps in the form of a python plug or something? Now that AD has a yearly subscription, I'll be able to upgrade Max one more time at least, but after that, who knows.  Unless business improves next year dramatically, I may be on the hunt for a replacement app.

It's always a good idea to learn other packages.  It expands your overall knowledge of CG, and makes you more marketable.  However, I really don't think I get the logic behind your reason for switching.  Consider that you already have an application with all the features you use regularly, as you've suggested, and the one you're thinking of replacing it with may not, so why switch?

You can actually ride your current version of 3dsMax a long way.  There's no need to upgrade it every year, unless there's something i'm missing behind your reasoning.

I'm still using v2012, and with the wealth of FREE plugins and scripts out there for it, I don't see any feature or requirement that leads me to believe I must upgrade any time soon.  The version is very stable (only 1 crash in about 6 weeks now, with heavy usage).  I've basically been putting some cash aside to upgrade to a version I really find I can't do without, whatever that may be.  In the meantime, I've got all the tools I find necessary, and anything I do find myself longing for, I can usually find in a free script or plugin on the various resource websites for Max.

Just because a new version comes along, it doesn't mean you can't continue to use the one you have.  I don't think AutoDesk has anything in it's licensing that restricts you from using their registered software for as long as you like, unless you're on the subscription plan.  I feel any version of Max greater than 2010 is very capable and can go a long way, particularly if you include the vast free library of plugins and scripts out there to add on to it too.  Just a thought.

______________________________________

My Store
My Free Models
My Video Tutorials
My CG Animations
Instagram: @luxxeon3d
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/luxxeon