I'm going to back us up a little here. The tools mentioned earlier are probably good, but I think the solution might be a bit easier than that. I'm going to go through the process a little more sequentially:

1. Load a figure, such as Michael 4.

2. Inject your favourite morphs.

3. Adjust dials until you get the desired look.

4. Save your Pose in the Pose library.

5. Start a new scene.

6. Load the same base figure as before.

7. Inject the same morphs as before.

8. Apply your pose.

When you save the Pose in step 4, it does not save the dial created by the morph injection. It only saves the value that you set the dial at. If you load a new figure, and apply your pose, nothing will change if you have not injected the morphs to create the dial first. The Pose only adjusts an already existing dial - it does not create the dial itself. You would need an injection Pose in order to create the actual dial, which is what the mentioned tools can do.