Zev0, of course it can be very good. I said in the post you disagreed with that it can be very good. It still can't be completely realistic. Look into the Uncanny Valley effect. CG may be beginning to scale the far side of that valley, but it hasn't gotten back out of it yet.

As for your reply being to my saying that CG can't be completely realistic yet, that's not what you specifically quoted out of my initial post to disagree with. In the future, perhaps you can say what you're disagreeing with, rather than expecting people to know that you meant something other than what you said?