Forum: Virtual World Dynamics


Subject: Aline Dress for test

VirtualWorldDynamics opened this issue on Aug 09, 2020 · 10 posts


DaremoK3 posted Thu, 20 August 2020 at 12:44 PM

Gérald, I downloaded and played a little with the Aline dress product (static sim only, so far) -- Here are my thoughts:

PROS:

CONS:

Now, these are more just based on personal taste of an experienced, advanced technical user, but I tried to put my mindset that of a newbie purchasing the product and having a play -- Just pushing buttons and see what happens (I know I cheated - I already knew the expected results).

I see what you are trying to do with this, but I think there are a few shortcomings for ease of use for newbies just purchasing for a quick sim with the cloth object.

I would put the cloth object auto-selected/imported and simulation auto-start in the PRO category, but it was too much of a guessing game just to get started, and I am a seasoned veteran -- Imagine a newbie purchasing not knowing what to do. You need to make the workflow very clear from the start.

Maybe, change it from having to press the Simulate header to an actual Cloth button like the Collision button (which auto-engages the Simulate header, go full-screen, and starts the sim as you have it)

Other than a not so clear start up, it is fine, but personally, I don't like it as a product. I believe the tool should not be included in the cloth product, and you should find another way to implement your auto-simple/non-pro quick sim clothing product to work with the already purchased tool.

Imagine you have 10 different cloth objects for sale and I purchase all 10 -- Now, I have 9 extra versions of the same crippled VWD to dispose of...

I like your idea for those who don't want/need full control, and just want a quick sim, but I think it should fall on the tool purchase side, and not the clothing side.

So, You already have the full VWD (let's call Pro), and a non-animation VWD version (let's call Standard). Maybe you should create a third VWD (this version in the cloth product), and call it something like Hobbyist or Quick Sim version. And, you can decide to make it free/available only for those who purchase a clothing product for it's use.