As hborre said (except for the "if you're skilled enough" part, the only skill this requires is having an image editor), Import your no makeup texture as a background layer in your image editor. Import your makeup texture as a layer above. Use the eraser to erase the eye makeup part from the makeup texture, revealing the no makeup texture below. Flatten image. Save as a new file...

---

W10 Pro, HP Envy X360 Laptop, Intel Core i7-10510U, NVIDIA GeForce MX250, Intel UHD, 16 GB DDR4-2400 SDRAM, 1 TB PCIe NVMe M.2 SSD

Mudbox 2022, Adobe PS CC, Poser Pro 11.3, Blender 2.9, Wings3D 2.2.5

My Freestuff and Gallery at ShareCG