Down for awhile meaning 1 year? Doubt either has made an extreme leap to make a difference "for me". Since this is a bit dated thread my input may help others with the same question.

Here's my opinion based off some simple observations and not actually comparing the functionality. Look at the quality of content for each program. Then look at the majority of renders posted by the users of each program. Look at the amount vender support. Look at the cost to produce your content. Then make a choice. Personally, I found it easy to make a decision.