Have always thought posette was cute. But she is stuck at the 18 year old barbie doll stage almost. Never liked eve since she posed badly to me since there was no poses that worked on her. Vicki's go goofy one way and posette's go goofy the other way and she couldn't wear clothes. But that is all a seperate issue. I say go for Vicki. Never been a big fan of Dina's unfortunately. Not saying it isn't well made but she doesn't please my eye for anything other than a variety person in the background and I can do that with Vicki.