I think it's wonderful! Maybe some puckers and folds around the waist, where the belt is cinching it in. The cloth shouldn't come out from under the belt so smoothly, and the little "blousing" effect above the belt could show more gravity, i.e., some weight pulling it down and maybe not sticking out sideways so much. But I love the garment. It's a more than welcome addition to Mike's wardrobe. I just love period clothing and I can't wait to see this in its final product. Great work! Melanie