promise me you will never ask the "perrenial" question again... what something is starts out originally from the artist, and then the viewer makes his or her own decision based on what the author has both said and put forth. It's photo if YOU want it to be, "2d" is YOU want it to be... now that that's out of the way, my comments and whatnot. First, I like what you did with the "window" in the picture. All in all, this demonstrates some skills Bev. Still, to my eyes, it seems a little flat for some reason, though I don't know why. I can't offer any suggestions, as I don't know what I find "wrong" with the picture, but something isn't clicking with my brain. then again, I'm just one guy with far too much time on his hands. Make sure you show up in the chat at 4pm (3pm rosity time)!