We already have a place to seriously critique images, in fact, we have 2 places. One, if theres a forum for it, whatever forum you made your image in, ask for comments and critiques. It usually works. 2, we have the comments box in the gallery which is meant for just such a thing. We've gained soething like 11 new forums in the past month and a half or so: zbrush, imagine, product showcase, art theory, mojoworld, dragon con, fractal, magazine interact, OT, texturing, and printing forums. In total, we have 49 forums (not counting admin forums), and 31 art galleries. Somewhere in that mess there is a perfect place to have our images critiqued already, by the proper audience audience.