I think this would be a really good idea .. a safe place to work out the kinks in an image..I would love to be able to give and receive ideas.. someone said above that you will get folks that do not know what they are talking about giving out advice .. I do not really think you need to know EXACTLY what you are talking about to know a shadow is giving a strange effect or a light is reflecting off something it should not.. or that for some reason something looks off..besides this could be a place to develop your "eye" so to speak. I have often said that Renderosity needs to take a bit of a step back in time .. When I first started to frequent the galleries I remember the comments were very constructive .. not often very sensitive ;-).. but wow I use to learn a lot reading them . At that time the critiques were fairly brutal .. now I would not want to go all the way back there (I was to scared to post g) but surly we can find a place in between? Besides you do not have to take ALL the advice given .. pick and choose. My 2cents.