Come to think of it, I guess the biggest reason I don't like the review form idea is because it takes out the entire reason I like the forum, which is because I want to DISCUSS images. It's not really a critique the other way, more like a comment card. In fact, I can't really see how any sort of form would tell me anything useful about my work. Ok. So I got rated a 4 on lighting and 5.6 on technical. What's that mean? Am I making any sense here at all? Maybe that sort of thing could be made available as an extra to the forum, but if that's all the forum was, I'd probably never bother. No offense, to anyone, btw... That's just my opinion. I think it's terrific people are taking the time to think so much about this thing, even if I don't agree with them. Regards, Paul P.S.: This is my last post for a while... honest... I'm shutting up now.... (Sorry about the spam - I know reading my posts here is starting to get like what happens when you use the VERBOSE command in Zork. )