Whatn I'm saying, Pablo, that I may not be getting across well, is that such a form being the first the person sees is going to make them think it's a necessity. Also, it would add clutter if every time I wanted to critique an image, or respond to another post, I'd have to deal with a long form like that. That's why I say that the idea should be accessible, while not being integral to the comments. Consider this thread, and what it would be like to carry on this conversation if a "form" popped up every time you wanted to respond. Also consider: The bigger threads take time to load for people with slower connections. Adding more information unecessarily would make it even slower, and a lot of people would just not bother. Guess maybe I'm a minimalist. I don't want to shoot your idea down, it just seems counter to the forum I have in my mind. Hence, the compromise of, why not put it there, but make it an extra that people can use if they want to? Regards, Paul