Nice use of lighting and characterization. They both communicate a story to me-which I like. These are all subjective ratings-in my art shows I find there are some pieces with a large popularity-but now and again someone has a particular favorite that really connects. I am not sure how the ratings should work-but I do think if I were to give a 4 amongst a sea of 5's I would say why. It may be that the image just did not appeal to Elpinio Eric W who gave 5's