Ok, I think this string is nuts, what olimpic athlete get's pefect tens. if all the inages (including the two that I have put up so far) are really five quality, how about all of theose at www.raph.com/3dartists/ Would they be 30 or 40? I have a lagit and honest criteque on the two. 2nd image: Ranking 3.5 to 4 Why: Nice use of position and form, and I love the use of color in reguards to the subject against the background. since they have the same value it blends well, but the shues bother me. there too bright on the side. The cloth texture has do depth to it, or bumpmap, thus it doesn't look like it does the figures justace, and the hair texture needs improvement. Framing is also kindof standard, I would play with camara angles, and maby make it an off center panoramic with something to conter balence in the empty space. You fix theose things and you'll eventialy have a rateing 5 image acording to my rateing scale. -Continued below