Forum: Photography


Subject: Voting Discussion

SueO opened this issue on Jun 26, 2002 ยท 13 posts


SueO posted Thu, 27 June 2002 at 2:33 PM

Jeff, well, you triggered it, and I think that is something to be proud of. I haven't been here long myself, certainly don't know everything I need to know (including apparently how to count LOL), and also, philosophically my stance is that everyone is better off if the cards are laid on the table. In an unfair world, it is the best you can do. And look at all the interesting points that came up. Like Jordy I also wondered if the form of the voting made a difference. In other words, when you vote by e-mail you really can vote only once (always assuming 1 screen name per carbon-unit LOL), but the other way, you could (I guess?) vote repeatedly for yourself to make sure you won. I've never tried voting more than once, so I'm not sure that there are electronic safeguards against such. It would be really dumb to force a meaningless win that way but certainly not outside the realm of possibility for some. None of our regulars I think would wish to win that way, but we are not a closed group. And if our regulars aren't voting in the contests they enter, then they are being deprived of their voice, and so are the rest of us, seems to me. They might honestly think their own is best, and they might honestly think someone else's is best. Just the fact that they are willing compete makes me interested in their opinion, you know? And, I see images I prefer to my own (because they are clearly better) every damn day of my life--it's the agony and the ecstasy of making images, if you ask me... Sooooooo what's the right thing, what's the best thing? The easiest thing is to leave it that the honorable thing to do is not to vote for yourself. But does it follow that you shouldn't even vote at all in that contest? By the way I think we have thirteen votes in for the Banner Contest. I have not voted, Alpha has not voted, and 3 of the 4 contestants have not. Just to emphasize my point, the contestant who DID vote, did NOT vote for their own image. Sue