No, merbliss. The software forums are, first of all, for software questions. Secondly, this only allows for technical critiques, as opposed to the non-technical merits. Theme, composition, etc. Furthermore, most of us work with more than one app. I use Poser, Bryce, and 3ds, and often post in Photoshop. While the Poser gallery tends to be more visible, I want users of various softwares to be able to critique my images... In this sense, I think the Rosity magazine is sort of going in the same direction, information that many users can use that cross-applies... Paul