fiontar opened this issue on Mar 05, 2000 ยท 18 posts
picnic posted Sun, 05 March 2000 at 12:32 PM
Actually the poster who gave the 2 didn't say anything about nudity--just 'what would she do when her skin was torn apart or shredded' (taking liberties in the quote). I guess the meaning was that this nude pose wasn't appropriate with a weapon, but nudity as the 'issue' wasn't called into question, at least IMO. I think the comment is pretty dumb, really--so I personally wouldn't worry about it. He/she didn't rate the image on the artistic OR technical ability shown--so--I'd say ignore it. Yes, I agree about the WIP thing as far as Foxhollow bringing it up, but I still think that if its an 'evolution' of a figure, then the forum would be more appropriate. However, if Fiontar considers this a finished image and not just showing us further developments in that particular image/character, then so be it. I personally like the character a lot--and will look for her again, but I think it would be fun to see it in the forum where a more 'in depth' conversation/critique' would occur. Fiontar, honestly, I don't think its a 'nudity' issue, but someone thinks she should have clothes on to use a weapon--well, that's sort of nutsy--just unfortunately, the score reflected an opinion that had no artistic or technical merit to it at all. Diane B