Rochr - 3 ICMgraphics - 2 FWTempest - 1 This was tough, ICMgraphics entry was actually closer to my vision of what Atlantis would look like, but the execution of Rochr's entry was a smoother, more integrated render. The FWTempest concept was also good, just not as polished of a render. All three put a lot of thought and time into their work and it paid off. Well done!