This is really hard. But here goes: Vasquez - 3 Alleycat169 - 2 Tuttle - 1 Here's why: Vasquez's is funny, that's for sure, but what appeals to me most is the gesture. I mean, look at that guy! I can really get into his mood. He knows he's in trouble and he wants to go back, but he's not returning for whatever reason. And the retro appeal is great. I really like this pic and I think the cartoony style helps the feeling and the gesture behind it all. Alleycat's just appeals to me. It stood out from the get-go. I like the composition, I like the color. I think the shadow from the ship is a little distracting though, but all in all, it's a very strong piece and I think the lens flares are refreshing because they're not in overpowering like they typically are. Pidjy's is familiar somehow. I'd swear I've seen that character before, but despite the cold character, the feel of the image is nice and warm. I like the idea that what appears to be machine is appreciating a simple, organic flower form. And I like that she's away from her companion to do it. Maybe her companion wouldn't understand, maybe she's putting it back, I don't know. It's a serene image, and it keeps me wondering about what she's doing with the flower form, why she's ventured off, and why she's on Planet X in the first place. Nice work one and all! There are a bunch of others that I was thinking strongly considering and I regret that I can only pick three. Again, great to see the variety and thought in this challenge!