Thanks for the comment Humorix.I feel an honorable mention from you actually more pleasing than votes.This is my fifth challenge now and the only votes I have ever recieved was for one of my worst pieces of work.I personally am not giong to change the way I look at the challenge because there is certainly room for different approaches.The vast majority of people did landscapes.That is a good point perhaps people should mention other pieces that came close in their voting or caught their eye in one way or another Good thread