I think the p5 render looks better in general. It's hard to tell without the same lighting, same poser, same character-- one variable at a time. As far as the figure goes, I don't like Judy's face. I think she's ugly and haven't been able to get an incredibly different face shape/structure without using the face room. And the faceroom makes the head not match the body and screws up the proportions. You can try and make the head match better by either using her original texture, or redoing the body texture to match your new faceroom texture.