I agree that we're getting too much 5's lately. My opinion to the suggestions above: 1. A rating between 1 and 10 would not solve the problem but make rating more difficult ("Should I give it a 7 or 8??"). Enough people will always rate top notch. 2. A separate jury rating seems very reasonable. Also the possibility to turn this on/off like the member rating. 3. Different ratings for certain aspects are complicated, time consuming and may be even unfair. Some pictures are simply great, even if the lighting is bad, or whatever. In conclusion: I would suggest to add a separate jury rating and leave the rest as it is. The only problem left will be electing the jury. Those jury people will have a lot of work to do in the future!