Hi All, Remember, there are only five ratings, no fractions, no decimals. So, the way I look at it: 5 = As good as the top 20%, or at least 80% perfect. :-) 4 = As good as the top 40%, above average, with some minor flaws. 3 = Top 60%, so-so image, with some good points but some distractions. If an image is a 3 or below, I usually won't rate it. If the artist and the image have potential, I may private message them some constructive criticism. I really think either a 1 to 10, or a 1 to 5 with some decimal choices would be best. My vote would be for 1 to 5, split into quarters, i.e. 5.0, 4.75, 4.5, 4.25, 4.0 etc... I think this option would be more compatible with the current ratings system, while allowing some greater breadth in ratings. Fiontar