thank you for the opinion. and yes of course every chart its kind subjective and always will be. But for me art chart for each gallery its only way to quickly see best renders/images posted lately in each gallery insted of browsing whole gallery..

ok..didnt see the posts...so I posted my opinion...but the problem and question is (if it had been already answered please let me know) I think either that hot20 was not perfect but I thougt that there will be new charts for each gallery for example for vue gallery so dont you think there should be art charts for each gallery ? rules for the art chart: For example.. 1 comment - 1 point and 1 favourite 5 points. Renders with most points will be at art chart for each gallery. Thats only idea and I would like to know what's your opinion..thats all

@pmermino I have never thought that listing one of your renders as a example of a excellent and artistic work could dissapoint you...I am sorry for that...I can delete the link if you wish

@aeilkema you dont know what are you talking about !!!! czarnyrobert is one of this artists which share almost all knowledge he has..He wrote several tutorials http://www.renderosity.com/tut.ez?Form.ViewPages=703 http://www.graphique3d.republika.pl/ and always explains how he made a render under ALL HIS IMAGES.

so here is my explanations: First of all I was talking about vue gallery at renderosity not a whole site: KITSH - in my opinions its a 15 minutes render made just to post something @wabe "Oh well, how about helping people to do better? It is always easy to complain but not to participate and help - with comments critiques or answering technical questions." I was trying to post a critique comments many times but next comments stopped me from doing @dlk30341 so here are my examples of kitsh http://www.renderosity.com/viewed.ez?galleryid=909945 http://www.renderosity.com/viewed.ez?galleryid=909926 http://www.renderosity.com/viewed.ez?galleryid=911183 to compare a few excellent renders: http://www.renderosity.com/viewed.ez?galleryid=511861 http://www.renderosity.com/viewed.ez?galleryid=553894 http://www.renderosity.com/viewed.ez?galleryid=907221 Generally I agree with most of your opinions but: - how can we help the community if "15 minutes renders" get excellent ranks ? - how could we improve the quality of renders if there are no any critique comments ?

Let me join to the appeal.
The level of great majority of renders in vue gallery is very poor. There are only few artists which art is worth seeing and comenting. In my opinion 90% of all renders in vue gallery is a simply KITSCH and nothing more.
Poor renders get excellent ranks and the overall level is going down
We are all responsible for this..so lets do somethong with it !!!!!!

Message edited on: 03/19/2005 15:42

#2

Goodbye Guitta. Thank you for all

VERY SAD ;((((((

Congratulations rodluc2001 on winning the April Challenge. Fantastic render and thanks everyone for so many entries.

11

Thank you veru much for kind words :)

@elektra
No, it must not...but the model must be a main part of the scene

Thank you veru much...Its second time I took part the Challenge and its second time I win..I am a very lucky men :) Thank you once again :) cermit

Thank you very much for your AMAZING support :)