Forum: Photography


Subject: B&W Film?

Misha883 opened this issue on Jan 12, 2003 · 26 posts


Misha883 posted Sun, 12 January 2003 at 6:46 PM

Black and White Films

I have not used B&W film for several years. [Part of this thread is to answer the question: "Should I?"] I mainly shoot color (negative), and convert to monochrome in Photoshop using the channel mixer. However, dedicated B&W films are still manufactured, and may offer benefits in grain, sharpness, dynamic range, low-light capability, etc. Do folks here have any opinions?  [Silly question...] I know I can read the manufacturer's Marketing sheets, but somehow that is not as comforting as hearing from actual experience.

Film Speed Dynamic Range Grain Sharpness Developer
Agfa APX  400
                  100
Ilford PAN 400
         PAN 100
Ilford HP5  400
          FP4  125
          PAN F 50
Ilford Delta  400
                   100
                  3200
Kodak PX125
Kodak T-Max 400
                       100
                      3200
Kodak TX-400

Film Speed Dynamic Range Grain Sharpness
Konica VX 400
Ilford XP2 Super
Kodak T400 CN
Kodak Portra 400BW