Josh101 opened this issue on Apr 28, 2003 ยท 6 posts
Josh101 posted Mon, 28 April 2003 at 9:01 AM
I have a few usage questions for the forum. Some may not be incorrect because of any rules, but may be more style issues. I'm not really sure and would like some opinions. If you reply could you state specific grammer rules or explain the style issue involved? Thanks everyone!
What is the correct way to say this sentence?
"Do this with a keyboard hit just like the examples and the book code does it."
OR
"Do this with a keyboard hit just like the examples and the book code do it."
Is it "do" or "does" and why?
"What is the speed of dark?"
"What is the speed of darkness?"
I read the first of these sentences in L.M. Boyd's column. What is the difference between the two? Is either one incorrect? What does the ness suffix connotate that the first doesn't? (By the way, the speed of dark is the same as the speed of light. :) )
"He wanted to leave as quickly (quick, fast?) as possible."
Do useage rules say that I have to use an adverb here or can I use either "quick" or "fast" without breaking any rules? Do any of the options give the sentence a slightly different feel or meaning?
"It is that one pitch in a thousand you see in slow motion; its wings beat (beating) slowly as a hawk's."
I read this sentence somewhere and wondered whether "beat" was correct or whether it would be better to use "beating"? Is one way or the other more correct? What's the difference?
"My index finger hovered over the trigger, brushing (brushed) against it, caressing (caressed) it as I contemplated what I was about to do."
Possible changes to this sentence are in parenthesis. I'm not sure if the original sentence is correct usage or if it just gives the sentence a more immediate feel. But in that sense should I also change "hovered" to "hovering"? Should I keep my ing's and ed's consistent or does it really matter? Is there any rule that states whether I should do it one way or the other? What is the difference bettween the ed and ing suffixes and what different meanings do they bring to a sentence?
Thanks again for any help you can give me here. No matter how much I read about grammar I keep coming across or writing sentences where I'm not sure of correct usage.
Thanks,
Josh
pakled posted Mon, 28 April 2003 at 9:28 AM
Er, bein' Southern and all, this may not be accurate, but as I would do it. 1)Press the keys as indicated by the book. I think some of the words are superflous, and tend to obscure what you're trying to say. 'do it' works fine in a trailer park, anything outside the lot would be 'does it'..;)
I wish I'd said that.. The Staircase Wit
anahl nathrak uth vas betude doth yel dyenvey..;)
dialyn posted Mon, 28 April 2003 at 9:57 AM
Just a quibble in #1...I don't think the book indicated anything, unless you have a talking book. I think there may have been an example in the book, or an illustration in the book, or instructions in the book. So I would rephrase the sentence as "Press the keys as shown in the example." I don't know that "book" is necessary unless it is possible they would be looking at something else. I think there is some poetic license in #2 that has nothing to do with grammatical correctness.
Crescent posted Mon, 28 April 2003 at 11:20 AM
mysteri posted Mon, 28 April 2003 at 12:41 PM
Josh101 posted Tue, 29 April 2003 at 8:58 AM
Thanks to everyone who replied. One thing we can all count on is the quick responses to forum questions. Granted, a few of these sentences were convoluted. They could have been rewritten so that the grammar issue went away, but this was how they were written when the question arose so I left them that way. I imagine many rough drafts have a bit of "trailer park" language in them. :) Of course, many great writers have no qualms about breaking the rules of grammar, but they usually have a good reason for doing so, and they are usually aware that they are doing it. My weakness as a story teller is my grammar, and at this point in my writing life I prefer not to butcher the language any more than necessary--if I can help it. :) Thanks again for the responses. You have clarified some issues for me and given me other issues to think about. Thanks, Josh