Pen_Is_Envy opened this issue on Jun 13, 2004 ยท 58 posts
Pen_Is_Envy posted Sun, 13 June 2004 at 7:42 PM
I must offer my SINCEREST apologies to anyone who so far has purchased a Cimerone product in order to prepare for entering my "Romance Long Ago" contest which starts June 21st. Poser forum moderator Shoshanna has just informed me about 10 min ago by IM that it IS in fact illegal in the state of Tennessee (where Renderosity is located) to run a contest which involves ANY kind of purchase. While my contest didn't demand a purchase (ie/ people who already owned a Cimerone product could use that and not purchase anything new), it was implied that anyone who did NOT yet own something from Cimerone's store would need to purchase one in order to participate. It is my understanding that Cimerone has had a great many sales over the past few days since the original announcement for this contest went out... SO, now that we cannot require the use of one of her products, I am going to increase the prize values for the contest... and for anyone who is offended that they spent on something of Cimerone's and didn't "need" to, please contact ME by IM, not Cimerone, and I will arrange to have Cimerone send you a link to her next product, free of charge. That being said, I have increased the prizes for 2nd and 3rd place, so more people have a chance to win a great prize. HERE ARE THE RULES: 1. Contest will begin on Monday, June 21, 2004 at 12:00 am Renderosity server time (they are on CENTRAL Time, CST), and end at 11:59 pm CST on Friday, July 30, 2004. This means you CANNOT post anything before the start date, or your entry will not be considered... 2. THEME: ROMANCE LONG AGO - You are to depict a romantic scene that could be found on the cover of a romance novel, and it must be set in a "long ago" time... which could be the Old South, Medieval Times, Victorian England, the Italian Renaissance, the Gothic Era ... ANYTHING that predates the 20th century (meaning 1900). 3. Image must be displayed in portrait format, ie/ an example being 8x10 inches, or 600x800 pixels. Anything in landscape format will not be considered. (use the sample image here as a guideline) 4. The image MUST have two Poser characters in it, one male and one female (Vicki/Mike, Steph/Mike, DOrk/Posette)-- NO nudity, with the exception of a possibly bare male chest, as mainstream romance novel covers are frequently depicted in this fashion. There also must be some kind of landscape background behind them, ie/ whether painted, rendered in Bryce, Vue, or what have you (these can also be from any background pkgs which can be purchased or found in free stuff). 5. You must have a title for this novel printed RIGHT ON your image, using whatever text format you like, and your name as the author's name also printed ON the image (see sample image here) -- but in order that I be able to find these in the gallery when I do a search, the gallery title to the image must be "Romance Long Ago" <--typed EXACTLY like this, minus the quotations obviously 6. ONE entry per person ONLY. NO collaborations allowed. Any software can be used, so long as the figures are Poser figures. Postwork is ALLOWED. 7. Comments and ratings MUST be DISABLED on any image submitted to this contest, or your image will not be considered. 9. Work must be YOUR OWN WORK -- ripoffs from other artists will automatically be disqualified. 10. Work must also be NEW and not previously seen in any gallery. (Sample image here is older [repainted hair], but is used as format/theme example ONLY) PRIZES: 1st: - $50 gift certificate to the Renderosity Marketplace purchased by me - choice of ANY 5 items from Cimerone's store - custom screensaver for your work (by ann0314) 2nd: - $25 gift certificate to the Renderosity Marketplace purchased by me - choice of ANY ONE character from Stormi's store (note: items from Stormi's collabs with other artists are ineligible) - custom screensaver for your work (by ann0314) 3rd: - $10 gift certificate to the Renderosity Marketplace (from anonymous donor<--I already have the $$) - custom screensaver for your work (by ann0314) (note: one prize may be added here) JUDGING Same as my last contest, plus the winner from my last contest: Crasher. Judges' decisions are FINAL. HAVE FUN! :O)!!!! SAMPLE IMAGE for the contest can be found in my gallery here: http://www.renderosity.com/viewed.ez?galleryid=692348&Start=1&Artist=Ferguson&ByArtist=Yes
PoisenedLily posted Sun, 13 June 2004 at 7:55 PM
I will be sorting over all my recent customers and sending out links over the next day for my newest brush set. You all will get it prior to its mainstream release. I hope no one will be upset with Ferguson over this, she was just trying to do something fun. I will rectify this situation to the best of my ability and hope no one regrets there purchases. The prizes still seem great :) CheeriO! Gina
Pen_Is_Envy posted Sun, 13 June 2004 at 8:00 PM
Jessie. :)
Again, I am SO sorry to anyone who will feel put out by having purchased only to enter the contest when maybe otherwise they wouldn't have. I hope this will be forgiven, it was a mistake, and it will not happen for the next contest. Note the "prize may be added here" for 3rd place IS the $10 gift certificate. In my haste to post the rules change, I forgot to take that part out, though I did add the prize*
Message edited on: 06/13/2004 20:07
Varian posted Sun, 13 June 2004 at 8:08 PM
Looking forward to seeing the entries to this one! :)
GraphicsMuse posted Sun, 13 June 2004 at 8:12 PM
Sounds cool to me. I needed Cimerone's brushes anyway so I don't mind all this ;o)
FlyByNight posted Sun, 13 June 2004 at 8:34 PM
LOL, I grabbed the brushes, too. They'll always come in handy. ;o)
FlyByNight
svdl posted Sun, 13 June 2004 at 9:10 PM
Well, I just looked into my stuff, and I found out I already bought two of Cimerone's characters. So this change of rules really makes no difference to me. I'll join, just for the fun of it.
The pen is mightier than the sword. But if you literally want to have some impact, use a typewriter
SpiceBunny posted Sun, 13 June 2004 at 9:35 PM
O_o regardless still, Cimerone's stuff is nice and i'll still participate :) hugs jessie
MistDragon posted Sun, 13 June 2004 at 9:35 PM
Cimerone I bought your hair brushes with intent to use for the contest, but I am so happy with them it doesn't matter to me about not having to buy anything after all :) Thanks Ferguson for the great contest idea!
MISTDRAGON
Pen_Is_Envy posted Sun, 13 June 2004 at 9:37 PM
Thank you guys SO much... I feel just terrible that I let this happen at all... but am humble and grateful for your generosity of spirit. :) Jessie.
On the plus side, there are better prizes now though, lol
Message edited on: 06/13/2004 21:37
Irish posted Sun, 13 June 2004 at 9:47 PM
Not your fault Jessie....please don't feel bad. You've brought a lot of pleasure with your past contest and I know you will with this one too. Nice to see this sort of spirit in our community. :)Irene
ann0314 posted Sun, 13 June 2004 at 10:35 PM
Hey sweetie don't loose heart :O) we all make mistakes and honestly those that bought Cimerone's brushes have been blessed...they are well worth it and for some of us it just gave us a nudge to try out painting hair...so good caqme out of it :O) You are SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO SWEET AND GENEROUS for doing anything at all...and I'm sure pepole will stop and realize that....you're the best :O) HUGS and thanks for all these wonderful contests...it is very generous and sweet of you.... :O) ann0314 :O)
Pen_Is_Envy posted Sun, 13 June 2004 at 10:36 PM
Thank YOU guys!! :O) You're making this very easy on me. :O) And now don't quote me on this, because it's still being looked into, but if all goes well, once this contest "goes live" on June 21, there will be a place for it on Renderosity's front page. IF this happens, contest images will be submitted to the contest area, just as they are currently being done for the Spring Fever contest. It would be great exposure for everyone's artwork too, I think. You'll see on June 21, on the front page, if it materializes Again, thanks all. :))
Message edited on: 06/13/2004 22:46
Wildflowers posted Sun, 13 June 2004 at 11:12 PM
Well all is clarify ;-) I would like to say, i buy something from Cimerone and is not just for the challenge !..Is for me too ;-D I don't regret anything! So we will make this beautiful challenge... with all the requirements! And no more problem of conscience for anybody! I find that Ferguson is extremly generous as regards the price. This is really nice She's keeps the same prices! Well is tiguidou my friend! :-D Wildflowers
rhiafaery posted Sun, 13 June 2004 at 11:56 PM
Oh Ferguson, thank you so much for this! I really wanted to enter this one, but money is pretty short this particular month and I couldn't afford to really pony up anything, although I wasn't mad at all about it, just figured this was one contest I wouldn't enter. :) Anyways, thank you again for your generosity, and after looking over Cimerone's store I think I will put something of hers next on my list when I get hold of some more money. :D
romanceworks posted Mon, 14 June 2004 at 12:18 AM
We already owned Cimerone hair brushes one and two - and LOVE THEM! So regardless of change in contest rules, we'll be using them in our image. But it's great that more people can participate now. Thanks for dreaming up such a fun concept, Jessie. Looking forward to seeing all the romantic covers.BTW - your "Bye Bye Blackbird" is wonderful.:o) Carol
beos53 posted Mon, 14 June 2004 at 1:51 AM
Can we base the art work we do on old popular song? I mean use that as a theme?
PoserPro 2014, Windows 7, AMD FX-6300 6 core, 8 GB ram, Nvidia
GeForce GTX 750 Ti
Pen_Is_Envy posted Mon, 14 June 2004 at 4:23 AM
Thank you, everyone!! And beos53, I'd rather you didn't do that, only to be safe regarding copyright. After all we've gone through with this contest so far, I think it's best not to base your image on anything other than your original concept (sorry to be a wet blanket there, just trying to be safe) -- I know that my sample image here, "Bye Bye Blackbird", IS actually the title of a song, but the image at any rate is not eligible for the prize, so it's "ok" in this instance (I hope -- if not, I will do a new sample image title NO PROBLEM).... but because there is profit to be gained from the contest, it might be an infringement for any images to do this... so just to be safe... PHew... I don't know if I just made this more or less confusing. hehe
Message edited on: 06/14/2004 04:31
elizabyte posted Mon, 14 June 2004 at 5:08 AM
Titles aren't copyrightable, and neither are song concepts translated into artistic interpretations. I could do an image called "Desperado" and so long as I'm not reprinting the lyrics or music of that classic Eagles song, I'm not in violation. ;-) NOT that I'm trying to second guess anyone. I'm just one of those people who doesn't like to see copyright myths perpetuated, and the "titles are copyrighted" thing is one of those. :-) bonni
"When a man gives his opinion, he's a man. When a woman gives her opinion, she's a bitch." - Bette Davis
Pen_Is_Envy posted Mon, 14 June 2004 at 5:29 AM
Ah well then GOOD!!!! beos53 there ya go. :O) I'm just a little on the paranoid side on the moment given my enormous faux pas with the start of this contest.
DarkStarRising posted Mon, 14 June 2004 at 5:45 AM
wow, what a shame, but at least those of us who havent purchased can now enter! seems a shame, and i never knew it was illegal, but i aint in the US so what do i know! anyway dont worry ferguson, we all understand the predicament, but we are all supportive of you no matter what, and those of you that do this wonderful contests too :D so keep yer chin up and smile!
In the words of DarkStarRising:
"Sadness within sadness,
Darkness within darkness,
a shadow of a form lays upon the floor,
looking at herself
looking at her own shadows of loneliness"
Pen_Is_Envy posted Mon, 14 June 2004 at 6:08 AM
:) Yep now everyone can enter and the prizes are better so... :) hehe Although I am sincerely sorry for anyone who might be offended by having purchased something when they didn't "have" to.
BellaMorte posted Mon, 14 June 2004 at 7:34 AM
Bookmarked :)
Lunaseas posted Mon, 14 June 2004 at 7:40 AM
kmw posted Mon, 14 June 2004 at 8:05 AM
Quote - MUST have two Poser characters in it [end quote] Does this mean it can't have more than two? i.e., a heartbroken woman watching her true love with someone else; a dog running alongside them, etc. Just wondering. kmw
Pen_Is_Envy posted Mon, 14 June 2004 at 8:09 AM
No that's fine, kmw, no problem. As long as there's the traditional man/woman depiction on it. We HAVE seen mainstream romance novel covers with a love triangle, so that's totally cool. :) OH, and I keep forgetting to mention this but a V3/V3 cover is OK so long as one of them is morphed as a male, so as to represent the mainstream romance novel cover. :))
SpiceBunny posted Mon, 14 June 2004 at 8:29 AM
lol ... stalking a bookshop and look at all the books with a woman/man images on it made the person in charge of the shop be suspicious of me. and i've yet to find woman/woman images or man/man images. but then, books like that are not approved, especially where i lived. for a person who owns less than 5 romance books - this is gonna be jolly fun.
Pen_Is_Envy posted Mon, 14 June 2004 at 8:38 AM
Oh I go into bookstores to browse the romance and fantasy sections all the time, just to look at the cover art. And no, you're right, SpiceBunny. In mainstream romance fiction, it's man/woman, and that's what we're doing here. Why I said using V3 and V3 is OK is because V3 does have male morph options that can make her look like a man, except for one thing, which will be covered by the clothing anyhow, so... it's all good. :))
hauksdottir posted Mon, 14 June 2004 at 8:42 AM
LOL! The only romance novel I've ever read was the one I proofed for a very good friend. At least we don't have to read the books, just eyeball the covers to guage the conventions. Carolly
Pen_Is_Envy posted Mon, 14 June 2004 at 8:53 AM
LOL, that's right!!! And of course the titles, since you're required to put a title on the cover as well.
elizabyte posted Mon, 14 June 2004 at 8:58 AM
i've yet to find woman/woman images or man/man images They're out there, but they're not really mainstream. There is a market for gay/lesbian romance novels, though. ;-) I've been reading romance novels (mostly historicals, but I read contemporaries now and then) for a very long time, as in, more than 25 years now. I read the "bodice rippers" and the pirate ones and all the other trends that these things go through... The cover art has changed considerably for some publishers, though, which is good. They used to all have "nursing mother" covers (so-called because the woman always had huge breasts about to burst out of her bodice), and then, somewhere, some genius though, "Wait! These are read by a largely female audience, what if we put a SEXY GUY on the cover?!" and suddenly Fabio had a career... ;-) I am planning on entering this contest. I'm working on the characters now, in fact. ;-) bonni
"When a man gives his opinion, he's a man. When a woman gives her opinion, she's a bitch." - Bette Davis
Pen_Is_Envy posted Mon, 14 June 2004 at 9:05 AM
YAY, Bonni, looking forward to it. And yup, I'm thinking mainly the Fabio TYPE covers for this contest. Some of that art is just gorgeous. ps/ My sister's name is Bonnie too... different spelling, but same name. :)
Vampir3Princess posted Mon, 14 June 2004 at 9:30 AM
Ohh!! This is really good news for me (and many others I know) :D Thanks for letting me know about the change of rules! You know I don't have a credit card and wouldn't be able to purchase anything from the market place but now that it isn't required you can count on my participation! :D :D Have a nice week Jess and all of you!! Muah! Hugs 'n Kisses Alejandra
Pen_Is_Envy posted Mon, 14 June 2004 at 9:49 AM
I think it did work out better for everyone concerned so that's great, and everyone has been really gracious, so... :) I'm looking forward to your artwork, Alejandra!! Gracias!
PoisenedLily posted Mon, 14 June 2004 at 10:29 AM
and suddenly Fabio had a career... ;-) elizabyte you just made me spit my coffee everywhere lol. That was hysterical lol. I truly appreciate everyones understanding in this. You are all very wonderful :) Now everyone HAVE FUN! lol (Hey I coulda said "Everyone wang chung tonight" lol) HUGS Gina a.k.a Cimerone
elizabyte posted Mon, 14 June 2004 at 10:35 AM
My sister's name is Bonnie too... different spelling, but same name. Bonnie was my grandmother's name. ;-) Oooh, Gina, sorry about that monitor! Hehehe. By the way, folks, Cimerone (Gina) makes fabu stuff, so check out her store even if you don't have to use a product for this contest. You won't be sorry! (And no, nobody's paying to say that, I really like her stuff :-) bonni
"When a man gives his opinion, he's a man. When a woman gives her opinion, she's a bitch." - Bette Davis
Pen_Is_Envy posted Mon, 14 June 2004 at 10:50 AM
:O)
PoisenedLily posted Mon, 14 June 2004 at 11:11 AM
Awww thanks elizabyte! You are too sweet. Gina
Elfenone posted Mon, 14 June 2004 at 12:53 PM
How lovely of you to personally inform me of this. I hadn't even had a chance to look the first time you told me of the contest so I was un-aware of anything needing changed. That's what I get for multi-tasking all the time. Ever feel the need for two heads and 4 hands?
Pen_Is_Envy posted Mon, 14 June 2004 at 12:55 PM
Yep, how about an entire clone of myself? So that one can do all the hard stuff and I can sleep. hehe And you're welcome. :))
Folded posted Mon, 14 June 2004 at 3:12 PM
Hmmm ... (going back and re-reading the rules) ... There wouldn't be a loophole in this where a dash of science fiction could peak through? Perhaps something like travelling through time? Picture H.G.Wells time machine in the back of the cover, or perhaps (dare I say it ...) the 'Enterprise' hovering low in the sky with a Kirk-like person (complete with uniform) wooing a local maiden fair? ... LOL!!! Sorry about the joke, (I'm a techie) but it just struck while reading through the thread here! (I've read a few of romance type books in my dark past, so do know what the theme really is;-) BTW: finding example covers to get the general idea from is just a google search away. Save the poor store clerk some stress:-) (Found one site with Fabio based covers already - http://www.fabioifc.com/BOOKCOVERS/FabioCovers.html)
Pen_Is_Envy posted Mon, 14 June 2004 at 5:04 PM
Actually, as great an idea as that is, Folded, that would have to be a no... because the time period must predate 1900. Maybe the next contest will be a scifi one!! :)) Doesn't have to be FABIO... just the idea of those painted historical romance novel covers... :O)
SpiceBunny posted Mon, 14 June 2004 at 9:28 PM
lol ... i found some sites that have romance bookcovers on it. lol. come to think of it - i dont remember bookmarking it!
Pen_Is_Envy posted Mon, 14 June 2004 at 9:33 PM
Avon books publishes the kinds of novels we're talking about here, or Dorchester press, or Harlequin Historicals... or writers like Kathleen Woodiwiss (some of her books), or Michele Hauf, ... HOpe that helps!!! OH, Samantha James, some of hers...Linda Needham... if you do a search on google or even at amazon.com, you should find plenty of examples. :)!! If you're still stuck, anyone, write again and we'll see what we can come up with.:D!
disneyfabfive posted Wed, 16 June 2004 at 1:41 PM
Would the size 500 x 600 be alright. I can't go 600 x 800 on my monitor and still have work area. Thanks, Beth
disneyfabfive posted Wed, 16 June 2004 at 2:44 PM
Here is a great site for ideas http://www.romancebookcovers.com/ Beth
svdl posted Wed, 16 June 2004 at 8:06 PM
disneyfabfive: work with a 450 x 600 work area (right proportions) and render to a new window as large as you want!
The pen is mightier than the sword. But if you literally want to have some impact, use a typewriter
disneyfabfive posted Wed, 16 June 2004 at 10:03 PM
Thanks will do Beth
kmw posted Thu, 17 June 2004 at 12:40 PM
Not to step over any one else's advice but you can take svdl's advice a step further. Depending on the size of your screen, here's what you do: create a window with the dimensions as close as you can get (Window/Document Window Size). Poser can create an 600 x 800. [I don't think it can go beyond 999 or something.] Okay, you've got this giant window taking up all your space (again, depending on your monitor). But here's whatcha do. Open Document Window Size a second time, check off 'Constrain aspect ratio' and change, say, the width to a more desirable size for your monitor. The height will adjust accordingly. Even if you click and drag now, the window will retain the ratio. Here's the final step: when you're ready to render, if you indeed need the larger size, render to a New Window. Make sure under Render Options you 'Match Document Window' and the 'Constrain' option is selected. Now type in 600 for the width and boom!, you should get 800 for height. (That's of course if your original document has the correct ratio.) Just another helpful hint from the Book of Ken. take care and hope it helps kmw
svdl posted Thu, 17 June 2004 at 2:32 PM
The maximum working window size depends on the resolution you're working with. I can set a working window size of 1585 x 1190 (at a screen resolution of 1600 x 1200). Render to new window can render to sizes almost as big as you want (depends on your amount of RAM) but I've seen sizes of up to 4000 x 4000 pixels! So you can make the final render almost as big as you want. Caveat- watch the background pictures, they might get really blocky and ugly. It's usually better to add a background pic in postwork. Hope this is useful info, Steven.
The pen is mightier than the sword. But if you literally want to have some impact, use a typewriter
elizabyte posted Fri, 18 June 2004 at 1:13 AM
Perhaps something like travelling through time? Actually, the "time travel" novel is a specific sub-genre of romance. There are plenty of them out there. Probably the best example would be Jude Devereaux's "A Knight in Shining Armour" (maybe it's Armor), a book which I would recommend to ANYone, not just romance fans. It's a wonderful and entertaining story with lot of comedy and romance. :) Generally, though, in the time travel genre you don't have too much focus put on the means of moving through time. It's some ancient magic spell or a prayer or stepping through a fairy ring or something of that sort. Sometimes they just get conked on the head and wake up in a different time... bonni (yes, I know a lot about romance novels ;-)
"When a man gives his opinion, he's a man. When a woman gives her opinion, she's a bitch." - Bette Davis
Pen_Is_Envy posted Fri, 18 June 2004 at 2:38 PM
Sorry for not responding sooner, I didn't get any ebots... disneyfabfive, if you want to do 500x600, that's just fine... although everyone here has offered some great advice so you'd be in good hands following that too. :)
and yes, time travel is a specific sub-genre of the romance novel, which CAN be done here only if the times depicted (both the one travelled TO and the one FROM) predate 1900. A Capt. Kirk type situation unfortunately would be too late for this contest, but maybe someone will have another one where it would fit. :))!!
ie/ on the book cover, the clothing would be one great way to convey the time period... the hairstyles another... even the background/landscape -- for example if there's a castle in the background (mind you the clothing and hair would have to correspond with this too).
Hope this helps!!
Jessie.
Message edited on: 06/18/2004 14:46
svdl posted Fri, 18 June 2004 at 2:56 PM
I was thinking of a time period WAY back - prehistoric in fact. In my opinion the prehistoric series of Jean Auel is about romance, not about history. Would that be acceptable? (I'll abide by the 'no nudity' requirement, they'll wear bearskins or something like that..).
The pen is mightier than the sword. But if you literally want to have some impact, use a typewriter
Pen_Is_Envy posted Fri, 18 June 2004 at 6:16 PM
Absolutely... I said before 1900, so YES!!... I think you could do a brilliant and beautiful romance cover with those subject!! ps/ The girl could be topless if she has long hair strategically placed, HEH!
hauksdottir posted Fri, 18 June 2004 at 8:29 PM
Lady Godiva riding on a cave-bear through Coventry? While the Mayor gallantly averts his eyes? :innocent whistle: Carolly (yes, that pun was intended)
Pen_Is_Envy posted Sun, 20 June 2004 at 10:59 AM
hehe
Pen_Is_Envy posted Mon, 21 June 2004 at 5:18 AM
Attached Link: http://www.renderosity.com/contest.ez?contest_id=356
There is a link to the contest right from the front page now... to get directly to the contest page, clink on the link provided here. :O) Have fun!! :)Armorbeast posted Sun, 27 June 2004 at 4:23 AM
Well I waited a bit to reply because I originally brought up the issue of the illegality of the requirement that Cimerones products had to be used to enter this contest...it may not have been by intent but without question to require Cimerones products be used did violate the law I knew without question because if you didn't have one of her products you couldn't enter-thus to enter you had to buy one of her products.For members who said well if you don't want to buy you don't have to enter...well thats the point,as soon as you made that statement you were acknowledging the illegality of this requirement...and it worked as we see an admission that Cimerones sales increased quite a bit as a result.Federal law itself requires that no purchase may be required to enter a contest and the fed has determined by in large to recognize what the states decide on their own beyond that. When I spoke with Cimerone about this she assured me that she had spoken with an attourney who told her it was legal and even why it was legal...unfortunately this proved to be misleading.Unless an attourney knows every law in every state,county or community in the U.S. they cannot make such an assumption...and yet here they did and two people who believed they were within the law find that in fact they were violating it. I do not say this to attack Fergusen or Cimerone...I say it because I have heard this so many times and had this same argument so many times.In every case someone who believes they know the law makes assumptions and tells you its ok to make a Ford Thunderbird prop for sale or a Marilyn Monroe character...wrong,it is 100% illegal to do so everywhere in the U.S. without the authorized approval of the product copyright holder or the person/estate of the person involved.You may make a Fyord Thunderhawk that looks almost like a Ford Thunderbird and be safe...you may make a character that everyone knows represents Marilyn but isn't an exact copy and uses a variation on her name like Mary Ann Marlows.The issue is when you sell these products...if the use of a name or likeness is used to sell a product then the person you've elected to infringe upon can take you to the cleaners-if its a freebie your ok.Answer then is to make the character or product free and find a way to sell accesories that go with it that aren't copyrighted. These are common sense issues...its like when someone on another site pointed out that Cimerone and Fergusen had this idea together before the contest was posted-they pointed out (before the topic was deleted by an overzealous admin)that this would constitute conspiracy and fraud-in truth if they did communicate about this beforehand and agreed to make the requirement that her product "must" be used,it would indeed constitute both.I don't think that happened...but these contests are going to be launched more frequently and aren't being monitored to protect members.If something goes wrong then all hell breaks loose in the forums afterward...I don't see why these matters will only be addressed "after" they erupt,these are generally cut and dry issues that could be addressed very simply and put in the TOS as recognized legal infringements of copyrights or free trade-even if everyone is not familiar with the law or the TOS,there are enough that are who could point to the possible TOS violation to help you. I am so glad that this matter was resolved early at the beginning of the contest rather than allow others to begin raising objections during the month that finally erupt in the forums and cause permanent rifts between friends that may be divided on the matter like it did during the BMO situation.I will have my own contest going next month honoring Kozaburo where we require you must use his hair products...but they're all free and I already checked to make sure its 100% legal since no required purchase to enter is being made.The funny thing is,I could ask that a donation be made to Koz,to me or a worthy cause and it be 100% legal...if you want to get around the law there are dozens of ways to do it legally as in Cimerone having a large number of freebies that people could have used-most people would still have bought items from her store,but a diverse number of freebies would have allowed anyone to enter and so the requirement would have been legal unless it was proven you discriminated against entrants that used the freebies.But at rosity she only had one freebie and there was no mention as to where others were that might be used...thus,it could be argued that people had to find ways to use that freebie in images where it made no sense and thus they were discriminated against in the final judging...there have indeed been contests where this was argued and the plaintiffs were victorious. So think...if we within this community allow violations to take place in regards to copyrighted material,then we can never hope to take legal action against people who steal the fruits of your hard earned labor.You can't argue that someone is giving your product away free on Kazaa if you illegally used a copyrighted product name without permission to make it...and if you obey the law,you fall victim because so many others don't and the community itself may in fact stand against you...we love our freedoms and don't want them infringed upon even if its for the common good,its always an interesting argument lol. And again,nothing against Fergusen or Cimerone is implied...just for a change someone in a better position to address the issue and who did so through the correct means has proven me right-in other csses I was correct but it was an argument among members and I was shouted down.I don't make issues to harm anyone,I only have good intent and when I'm right and know I'm right...its rough to be shouted down by a mob or have it erupt into flaming in these forums.So for once I feel vindicated and that maybe I prevented these two from violating laws that they were misled into believing they were not.Others will follow and unlike Cimerone and Fergusen,some of these people will truly be out to rip you off...be careful ok and hope this contest goes very well for Cimerone and Fergusen:)
If the end goal of learning is genius...why are most geniuses failures at learning?