Forum: Community Center


Subject: a word about rating here on renderosity - DREAMSPINNER

tekener opened this issue on Jan 23, 2001 ยท 14 posts


tekener posted Tue, 23 January 2001 at 6:01 AM

yesterday i have gone to DREAMSPINNERS gallery and give some comments about the pictures. i give comments like "there are no shadows, the picture looks to flat, no depth. try reworking the lighting.". i think this is a helpful comment! but russ cock has deleted all of this comments! i ask you WHY? is this not an helpful comment? why rating pics her on renderosity? give all pics 10 points and dreamspinner will be happy. who cares if the picture deserves 10 points and if someone makes a REALISTIC rating, go to russ cock and let him delete the comment you dont want. i give 10 poins for REALLY good PICTURES not for every amateurs standard water,sky and mountain bryce picture. i think russ cock has not read a single of my comments, and that makes me sad. if you want only comments like "wow thts nice" then dont write "make helpful comments for improvment". instead write "make nice comments on every picture". after DREAMSPINNER saw some of my comments he makes malicious comments about my person (tekener sound like a broken record etc.) he makes a picture for the "critic god tekener" (he has deleted this pic yesterday) with malicious comments about me. i made my comments in a CORRECT form without any personal animosity. dreamspinner is not an artist like HOBBIT or other artist here on renderosity, he is an average bryce user (no more no less). how should i rate a pic from hobbit, if every dreamspinner pic MUST be rated 10 or the rating will be deleted?